ONE-WAY STREETS IMPEDING BIKE SHARE SUCCESS

Final_GCC_logo_7_06_2010Galway Cycling Campaign welcomed the launch of the city bike share scheme (Coca-Cola Zero Bikes) a year ago, but its success was in doubt from the start once the planned station on University Road was not built.

City Hall, in a last minute U-turn, removed one of the three largest docking stations from the scheme due to concerns over loss of 4–5 car parking spaces. “The decision to completely remove a station capable of holding up to 30 bicycles, one of only three of that size, clearly showed the priorities of City Hall at the time. UHG and NUIG lost their primary docking station link to the city centre even before rollout,” said Robert Mc Kenny, Campaign Chair.

As of today, only 13 stations out of 15 are operational in Galway city. A total of 19 were meant to be built over a year ago. The greatest distance is between stations at Fr Burke Road and City Hall, which are 1.7km apart. Their proximity to one another is widely believed to discourage potential users.

City Hall’s decisions to omit planned docking stations and ignore recommendations on one-way streets did not bode well for the scheme from the start. It is no surprise to the Cycling Campaign that Galway’s is the least-used scheme nationwide by a significant margin. If it were expanded to the same number of stations as Limerick (23) or Cork (31), and if the one-way streets issue were dealt with, then it could match those cities’ usage numbers.

One-way streets lead to long detours for cyclists, as Campaign member Shane Foran explained. “There is a bike share station on Mainguard Street near St Nicholas Church. The distance to the next bike share station at Newtownsmith is 350m. Because of the one-way street system and a ban on cycling in the pedestrian zone, the return journey from Newtownsmith to Mainguard St. is 1.1km by the northern route and 2.1km by the southern route.”20150927_Market_St_Street_View_with_notes

The one-way streets problem has long been highlighted by the Campaign as a barrier to cycling in Galway. The Jacobs Report, which was the initial feasibility study for the bike share scheme, described Galway as “awkward to navigate by bike” and recommended providing two-way cycling on one-way streets – a common feature in other European cities. This has not been implemented. “Two-way cycling on one-way streets has been in the City Development Plan for a decade now, and the Jacobs Report stressed its importance in its Executive Summary,” said Campaign PRO Oisín Ó Nidh. “If Galway City Council had followed the recommendations of the Jacobs Report, then Galway would not be in last place.”

Further reading:

See our discussion paper: Addicted to cars; the role of car parking revenue for Irish local authorities and implications for state policy.

Appendix 1: Public Bike Share in Galway – Page 7

Appendix 2: The impact of one-way streets and disk parking on school children – Page 9

Comments (3) Write a comment

  1. I would like to see the half hour free use period be extended to 3 hours. It hardly makes any sense to use a bike for just 30 minutes. by the time you’ve gone to the trouble of wearing appropriate cycling clothes, gone to the bike, got the bike, put it back at the same or another station…you could have just as easily (if not more easily) have walked.

  2. Bikeshare schemes do not use the model you propose for a reason Mark. The bikeshare model of the first 30 minutes for free works in Dublin,
    Belfast and Cork because they have many more stations available to the Bikeshare users.
    If you want a long term rental, half a day or full day bike rental there are a number of options available in Galway City.
    Take one provider for example. West Ireland Cycling
    http://www.westirelandcycling.com/bike-hire/
    they also have a student bike rental
    http://www.westirelandcycling.com/student-bike-hire/

Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *.


Top